Your questions
We want a conversation, not a lecture. Here are the hardest questions we get. If you think we've got something wrong, say so publicly and tag it #HomesNotAssets.
If buy-to-let ends, where will renters live?
Homes don't disappear when a landlord sells. They get bought by the tenant, by a first-time buyer, or by a council or housing association. Not everyone wants to buy, and that's fine. Rented homes should come from councils, housing associations and not-for-profit landlords, not from someone outbidding first-time buyers for a two-bed terrace.
Won't rents go up?
Every home a landlord sells is bought by someone who no longer needs to rent. So there are fewer homes to rent, but also fewer people competing for them. That's why the phase-out has to come with more social housing, so that people who rent have secure, affordable options. [Policy detail to agree]
My rental flat is my pension. What happens to me?
We understand. For years people were told property was the safest pension there is. That's why we're proposing a long phase-out rather than an overnight change. You'd have time to sell at a fair price, ideally to the people already living there.
Isn't banning overseas buyers xenophobic?
No. It's about where you live, not where you're from. Anyone who lives in the UK, whatever their nationality, could buy a home. New Zealand, Canada and Denmark already restrict people who don't live there from buying homes. [verify]
Won't this crash house prices and hurt homeowners?
We don't want a crash. We want prices to stop running away from wages, and that's why the changes would be phased in over years. If you own your home and live in it, its price only really matters when you sell, and then you'd be buying your next home in the same market.
Has anywhere else done this?
- New Zealand banned most people who don't live there from buying existing homes in 2018.
- Canada banned most non-Canadians from buying homes from 2023.
- Barcelona plans to end all tourist apartment licences by 2028.
- New York City effectively ended most short Airbnb stays in 2023.
- Closer to home, Welsh councils can charge up to 300% council tax on second homes.
[Verify each and add to sources]
Who's behind this?
[Who we are, why we started this, and how we're funded: to write]